Family Law and Same-sex or Gay Marriage in Maryland

Same-sex Marriage Around The World

In 2001, the Netherlands became the first country to permit same-sex marriage, followed by Belgium (2003), Spain (2005), Canada (2005), South Africa (2006), Norway (2009), Sweden (2009), Portugal (2010), Iceland (2010) and Argentina (2010), who all grant and mutually accept marital unions between homosexual partners. In short, about Two Hundred Million people, or Four-Percent of the planet’s population, live in nations that recognize legal unions between gay and lesbian partners.

Legal recognition of same-sex marriage varies in the United States. This often seeds confusion, especially as it relates to domestic partnership rights. Maryland is not an exception to this confusion. In Maryland, the legal recognition of same-sex marriage is in flux.

MD same-sex marriage
Gay Marriage in Maryland
Iowa, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Vermont, New York and Connecticut are the only states, along with the District of Columbia to recognize same-sex unions. Rhode Island and New Jersey do not allow same-sex marriages, but do acknowledge same-sex marriages performed in other jurisdictions. It seems Maryland may or may not also fit into this category.

In 2010, Maryland’s Attorney General issued an opinion concluding that Maryland law may and should recognize same-sex marriages performed in other jurisdictions. However, this opinion does not carry the weight of law. In Maryland, only court rulings and legislative enactments can legalize marriage for same-sex couples.

Currently, a law passed by the Maryland House of Delegates almost 40 years ago states “only a marriage between a man and a woman is valid in this state.” However, recent legislative action in Maryland sought to change this law. A bill presented to the Maryland General Assembly would have redefined marriage from “between a man and woman” to “between two individuals.”

The legislative proposal in Maryland came at a time when opinion was swinging in favor of gay marriage. A 2010 Washington Post poll found that fifty-five percent of registered voters in Maryland supported a law allowing same-sex marriage, compared to forty-four percent in 2007. Therefore, in just three years a clear majority of registered voters would support the passage of a law permitting lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender (LGBT) couples to marry. Notwithstanding this overwhelming increase in support the bill failed. On January 20, 2012, lawmakers reintroduced legislation establishing that a marriage between two individuals who are otherwise permitted to marry would be valid in Maryland. The bill entitled The Religious Freedom and Civil Marriage Protection Act, HB55, will lock horns with HB474, entitled, the Maryland Marriage Protection Act, which was introduced weeks later by opponents to same-sex marriage. This bill seeks to amend the state Constitution outlawing same-sex marriage in Maryland.

Gay Marriage: Rights, Domestic Partnerships, & Family Law

So, what can homosexual life partners do if they wish to ensure themselves of all the rights and protections the law affords married heterosexual couples? The complete answer will very much depend on the jurisdiction where the same-sex life partners reside. The first part of that answer will lie in whether or not a domestic partnership is recognized by the local or state government where the parties reside; or by the employer of either of the life partners. The federal government still does not recognize domestic partnership and thus, unlike heterosexual couples, same-sex lgbt couples are not afforded the 1,138 separate rights conveyed to married couples by the federal government. In fact, the federal Defense of Marriage Act significantly complicates the situation for same-sex spouses raising serious tax consequences as just one example. Same-sex life partners will have to rely on recognition by their local municipalities and governments or turn to private legal contracts and agreements, such as domestic partnership agreements, child custody agreements, powers of attorney, healthcare directives, etc., which should be completed under the advice of counsel.

Matters in Maryland are in stark contrast to the District where same-sex unions are recognized. Maryland afforded just eleven protections for domestic partners, such as funeral arrangements, additions and removals to residential deeds without tax penalty, and hospital visitation. The General Assembly did not, however, establish a registry for domestic part-nerships which further complicates the legal aspects of gay marriage in Maryland.

Maryland Domestic Partnership Agreements & Legal Remedies

Gay marriage is too new to have reliable divorce rates. However, there is no reason to think that it will differ from the forty to fifty percent national divorce rate experienced by heterosexual couples. This raises an interesting quandary for same-sex couples. What sort of legal structure should be established to help navigate the complex maze of issues that accompany a breakup? Heterosexual couples have the benefit of access to family court and the well established precedents and legal rulings. In states that do not recognize same-sex unions, this guidance may not be available to same-sex couples. Whether in a locale that recognizes gay marriage or not, several legal steps should be considered:

(1) Proof of Partnership- since the Maryland General Assembly has not yet established a registry for domestic partnerships, couples may be faced with having to prove that their domestic partnership exists. This means same-sex couples may have to prove the partnership through sworn affidavit and at least two sets of documents enumerated in the Maryland statute, such as a joint checking account, mortgage statement, or joint insurance coverage, in addition to others. This has been the law in Maryland since July 1, 2008.

(2) Domestic Partnership Agreements- which may provide for the division of assets and liabilities, as well as define the rights of each partner in the event of a separation and/or termination of the relationship. This is especially important in states like Maryland where same-sex divorce will not have the benefit of family law precedent.

(3) Child Custody Agreements- to define both legal, physical and visitation/access to minor children of the same-sex relationship, as well as powers of attorney, healthcare directives, and other documents that assist in times of emergencies where crucial deci-sions regarding the health of a same-sex partner needs to be made rapidly. These documents should be tailored for each couple under the advice of counsel.

Making Sense of Gay Marriage, Divorce, & Family Law in Maryland

Unfortunately, there is no easy answer when it comes to same-sex marriage and family law in Maryland. Unlike heterosexual marriage, there is no legal precedent or case work upon which to rely. The issue is made even more complex by federal obstacles such as the Defense of Marriage Act. This means that same-sex partners wishing to establish a civil union or marriage must act in their own interest and take the necessary protective legal actions. Divorce is emotional, difficult, and life changing. Clear legal guidelines established from the beginning will greatly benefit both partners and any children or other family members involved.

About Brodsky Renehan Pearlstein & Bouquet, Chartered

Brodsky Renehan Pearlstein & Bouquet is one of Maryland’s and Washington, DC’s foremost practitioners of family law. All of our personnel and systems are committed to the aggressive and diligent pursuit of divorce and family law litigation. Our singular focus on family law means our clients receive the most efficient representation and best opportunity to achieve their goals in the areas of divorce law, child support, custody issues, alimony, property division, high asset cases, domestic violence, pre-nuptial agreements, and e-discovery.

Brodsky Renehan
Pearlstein &
Bouquet, Chartered
16061 Comprint Circle
Gaithersburg, MD 20877

Maryland calculates child support using specific guidelines. This makes child support payments in Maryland predictable and uniform unless you exceed the income threshold. Read More
Recent Blog Posts
Litigation in family law cases often involves expert testimony. Expert testimony can be important to establish facts that affect the amount and duration of alimony. Read More